A Visit to a Sad Planet

18/04/2017

One of the things that always irked me about my EPUB reader was that part of it is written in JavaScript, simply because that’s the only way one can script a browser view these days. I’ve always wanted to give the SPOCK compiler a try to see how well it does compared to ClojureScript, so this project gave me the perfect chance to cure me of delusions. After an evening, I got it running, it took me a few more evenings to iron out bugs introduced by the conversion and add a new bugfix. Here’s a list of observations made in that time:

To summarize, if you want maximum comfort and features, go for ClojureScript. The price you pay for it is significant friction while developing, but other than that it’s pretty advanced. Personally I think I’ll stay with vanilla JavaScript for my other toy projects to keep things as simple and painless as possible.

I predict that Guile Emacs won’t lead to a significant increase in packages written in Scheme for similar reasons. Much like in browsers, the majority of Emacs Lisp usage doesn’t have complex business logic and follows the principle of practicality over purity. Perhaps it’s different for big projects like Magit or Evil, but even these cases are doubtful to me, simply because they have higher priorities than speculative rewrites that might as well kill the project. I could keep rambling about my reasons for this assessment, but that is better left for a separate blog post…